Navigating Change: Strategies for Government Leaders During Agency Restructuring
In today’s dynamic governmental landscape, agencies and departments often undergo restructuring to adapt to evolving missions, priorities, and challenges.
In my 15 years in state government I went through at least five restructures, my guess is you have been through this and even more! Responses to these restructures, realignments, rationalisations – whatever they were labelled – were always broad and varied. Some people panicked and went into flight, fright or freeze, some people were apathetic saying they’ve seen it all before, been here before, got the T-shirt, others were angry and resentful for being put through the drama and insult of having to apply for their longstanding role yet again.Needless to say, while restructures can make complete sense on the strategy and paper level, the flow on impact and ripple effect on the humans involved can be greatly underestimated.
Absolutely as time passes and technology, processes and society changes, businesses and government need to shift to reflect those changes. Roles and tasks can often become redundant, new projects and needs arise making change necessary. In my experience the grief and interference isn’t always positive or effective, in fact it can often reflect the psychological cycle of violence. There’s a period of anticipation and anxiety, an event – the rationalisation which can be a period of complete disarray and heightened activity and frustration (I call it the messy middle) and then a period of recovery and receding while people recalibrate to the new way of operating, the loss of colleagues, new roles, new teams etc and then a honeymoon period of returning to BAU while we try to pick up the pieces and get back to productivity, until the next whisper of a restructure returns us to the anxious phase again. Around and around we go!
Research indicates that the success s rates of organizational restructures vary widely across different industries, sectors, and specific contexts. While some restructures achieve their intended goals and improve organizational performance, others may fall short due to various reasons such as implementation challenges, resistance to change, or unforeseen external factors.
For directors and senior leaders, navigating through such periods of change requires more than just managerial acumen—it demands effective leadership to guide teams through uncertainty and ensure continuity of service delivery.
Here are some of the essential strategies and techniques that leaders can employ to successfully steer their organizations through an organisational restructure:
Understanding the Context of Agency Restructuring
Agency restructuring can stem from various reasons, including shifts in political priorities, budget constraints, organizational inefficiencies, or the need to realign with new mandates. Regardless of the catalyst, restructuring introduces uncertainty among employees, raises concerns about job security, and may disrupt established workflows and team dynamics. Effective leadership during these times is crucial not only to maintain operational stability but also to inspire confidence and foster resilience among staff.
The Role of Leadership in Times of Uncertainty
Leadership during agency restructuring goes beyond issuing directives; it involves empathetic communication, strategic decision-making, and proactive engagement with stakeholders. Leaders must recognize the emotional impact of change on their teams, understand that each individual is at their own stage in the process and provide reassurance while simultaneously driving forward the agency’s mission.
Effective Leadership Strategies for Navigating Agency Restructuring
1. Clear Communication
Clear and consistent communication is paramount during periods of uncertainty. Leaders should openly address the reasons behind the restructuring, its expected impact, and the vision for the future state of the agency. Transparent communication builds trust and helps mitigate rumours and misinformation that can undermine morale.
Reference: According to Kotter's 8-Step Change Model (1996), effective communication of the vision for change is crucial to gaining buy-in from stakeholders.
2. Engagement and Involvement
Engaging employees in the restructuring process fosters ownership and commitment to the agency’s goals. Leaders should seek input from staff at all levels, encourage constructive feedback, and involve them in decision-making where feasible. This participatory approach not only enhances morale but also generates innovative solutions and buy-in for proposed changes. In particular it is imperative that you genuinely engage with employees – don’t say this is a period of consultation if the changes are already determined and locked and loaded. Be honest about the change and how much influence they will actually have in the process.
Reference: In their study on employee engagement during organizational change, Armenakis et al. (2007) emphasize the positive impact of involving employees in decision-making on organizational commitment and performance.
3. Resilience Building
As restructuring can create uncertainty about job roles and future career paths it can bring up all sorts of anxiety and concern amongst employees (and in yourself). Leaders should actively support their teams by providing resources for skill development, offering mentorship opportunities, and facilitating career planning discussions. Building resilience among employees equips them to adapt to change and emerge stronger from challenges.
One of the biggest challenges I saw in the past was a manager who was required to support their staff and remain positive and upbeat, helping plan the work ahead through a major restructure where the workforce in their departments would be cut by 30 per cent. The punch in the face was that the manager themself was also about to lose their position. Leaders, remember to put your own mask on too and really look at the positions you are putting people in.
Reference: The American Psychological Association (APA) outlines strategies for building resilience in the workplace, including fostering optimism, promoting social support, and encouraging self-care.
4. Managing Resistance
Resistance to change is natural and can manifest in various forms, from passive disengagement to active opposition. Leaders should anticipate resistance by understanding its underlying causes, addressing concerns empathetically, and communicating the benefits of the restructuring. Proactively managing resistance helps maintain momentum and facilitates smoother implementation of change initiatives.
A model I have always found helpful during change processes is the ADKAR model. By focusing on these five elements, the ADKAR model helps manage the human side of organizational restructures, making the transition smoother and more effective.
Here’s how each component of the ADKAR model can be applied:
Awareness: Ensuring that all employees understand the reasons behind the restructure. This involves clear communication about the goals, benefits, and necessity of the change. Awareness helps reduce uncertainty and resistance.
Desire: Fostering a willingness among employees to support and participate in the restructure. This can be achieved by addressing concerns, highlighting personal and organizational benefits, and involving employees in the change process.
Knowledge: Providing the necessary information and training to employees so they know how to adapt to the new structure. This includes understanding new roles, processes, and expectations.
Ability: Ensuring that employees have the skills and capabilities to implement the changes. This might involve additional training, resources, or support to help them transition smoothly.
Reinforcement: Implementing mechanisms to sustain the changes over time. This could include regular feedback, recognition of efforts, and continuous support to ensure the new structure is maintained and any issues are promptly addressed12.
References: Kotter and Schlesinger (1979) identify four common reasons for resistance to change—parochial self-interest, misunderstanding and lack of trust, different assessments, and low tolerance for change—which leaders can address through targeted strategies.
5. Cultural Alignment
Organizational culture plays a pivotal role in shaping how employees perceive and respond to change. Leaders should assess the current organizational culture, identify cultural barriers to change, and promote values and behaviours that align with the desired future state. Cultivating a supportive and adaptive culture facilitates smoother transitions and enhances organizational resilience.
Reference: Schein’s (1985) model of organizational culture emphasizes the importance of shared values, assumptions, and behaviors in influencing organizational responses to change.
7. Monitoring and Adaptation
Effective leadership during agency restructuring requires a dynamic approach to monitoring progress and adapting strategies as needed. Leaders should establish clear metrics for evaluating the impact of restructuring initiatives, solicit feedback from stakeholders, and remain agile in responding to unforeseen challenges or opportunities. Continuous monitoring and adaptation ensure that the agency remains responsive to evolving circumstances.
One of the biggest challenges I have seen working with leaders in agencies is undertaking the complexity that all this change brings while still trying to support their team to conduct a semblance of BAU, delivering for customers and adapting to these changes. Most organisations underestimate the sheer volume of work and mental load of all these complex challenges happening at once.
Reference: The Balanced Scorecard framework (Kaplan & Norton, 1996) provides a structured approach to monitoring organizational performance across multiple perspectives—financial, customer, internal processes, and learning and growth.
8. Supporting Wellbeing
The stress of organizational change can take a toll on employee wellbeing. Leaders should prioritize supporting the physical, emotional, and mental health of their teams through wellness programs, access to counselling services such as EAP, and promoting work-life balance. A healthy workforce is more resilient and better equipped to navigate the complexities of agency restructuring. In particular, if a group of employees have been through a number of restructures over several years you may find that their ability to bounce back diminishes each time. You cannot underestimate this and so continued conversations about how people are going is essential – for them and for yourself.
Reference: The World Health Organization (WHO) emphasizes the importance of workplace health promotion programs in enhancing employee well-being and organizational performance.
Conclusion
In conclusion, effective leadership is pivotal in guiding agencies through periods of restructuring. By employing clear communication, fostering employee engagement, building resilience, making strategic decisions, managing resistance, aligning organizational culture, monitoring progress, and supporting employee well-being, leaders can navigate uncertainty and lead their teams toward a successful transition. Embracing these strategies not only mitigates risks associated with restructuring but also positions the agency for sustainable growth and excellence in public service delivery.
References
Armenakis, A. A., Harris, S. G., & Mossholder, K. W. (1993). Creating Readiness for Organizational Change. Human Relations, 46(6), 681-703.
Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading Change. Harvard Business Review Press.
Kotter, J. P., & Schlesinger, L. A. (1979). Choosing Strategies for Change. Harvard Business Review, 57(2), 106-114.
Kaplan, R. S., & Norton, D. P. (1996). The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action. Harvard Business Review Press.
Mintzberg, H. (1976). Planning on the Left Side and Managing on the Right. Harvard Business Review, 54(4), 49-54.
Schein, E. H. (1985). Organizational Culture and Leadership. Jossey-Bass.
World Health Organization (WHO). (n.d.). Workplace Health Promotion. Retrieved from https://www.who.int/occupational_health/topics/workplace/en/
PLEASE FOLLOW me, (2) AJ - Alexandra Joy GAICD - (on Wonnarua and Darkinjung Land) | LinkedIn for more inspiring Leadership, Culture, Soft Skills, Coaching and Daily Uptimism and Insights 🚀
#Restructure #Leadership #AskForHelp #LeadershipCoaching #SuccessMindset #GovernmentLeadership